Building with Leaves Stripe
Huntingdon College program in Political Science and LAS Justice Symposium

Film Notes, Costa Gavras, Missing.

With Jack Lemmon and Sissy Spacek.
This film won the Palm D'Or (best Film) and Best Actor award (Jack Lemmon)
at the Cannes Film Festival; the Grand Prize of the Writer's Guild of America
and the Oscar for Best Screenplay.

Notes, background, and questions by Jeremy Lewis
Last revised 18 Mar 2001; click your Refresh or Reload button to see latest.

Index.
CorkPSC Outlines Index
CorkJustice Timetable
CorkPSC Courses Index
Mail IconComments
CorkPSC Home Page
CorkJustice Syllabus
Film Notes 
Top Icon
Background of Political Turbulence.

The setting is the 1973 Chilean coup d'etat of the army against the newly elected socialist party government of Salvador Allende Gossens.  Multinational corporations such as Anaconda copper mining and ITT communications, fear the nationalization of their assets by the new government.  Some are large contributors to the Nixon campaign.

President Nixon and National Security Advisor Henry Kissinger decide (As Kissinger put it) not to let a country go socialist owing the irresponsibility of its own citizens. 

When US economic blocking (and a truckers strike) fails to dislodge the party, US intelligence is ordered in to overthrow the government.  The Chilean army has remained out of politics for 150 years, but changes its mind when General Schneider is assassinated by a rocket attack on his car, and General Pinochet takes power.  The presidential palace in Santiago, the capital, is bombed, Allende is shot, and some 50,000 young men (often students) are imprisoned in the soccer stadium and interrogated, tortured or even murdered.

US special forces are seen in Santiago, and US naval warships offshore are assisting with communications.  In Valparaiso, US naval officers are at work.

In the US there is a counter-culture of students and hippies by this time protesting angrily against the Vietnam war and the business culture that supplied it.  In Chile, a few US citizens, other than covert soldiers, are at risk: hippies and students who are helping the poorer neighborhoods, a gentle people unable to withstand military force.

The non-fiction Book and Film.

The story begins with a circle of young people in Santiago de Chile, friends, helping the poor and living among them.  Their peaceful world is torn apart by shots in the street, signalling the coup.  Violent repression greets anyone who ventures into the streets during the curfew.  Even obtaining news about the disappearance of friends becomes dangerous.  Homes are ransacked.  Charles Horman happens to have done some translation (to make ends meet) for a socialist newspaper.  Charles and his pal Frank Terruggi fail to return.

Enter the father, Ed Horman (Jack Lemmon) looking for his lost son Charles.  A businessman with military contacts and a loyal republican contributor, he is not entirely comfortable with his son and daughter in law (Sissy Spacek) with their alternative lifestyle.  He must gradually come to the understanding that his own government may have declared his son a subversive, and assisted in his torture and murder.  His daughter in law must lead him to this realization without herself suffering the same fate.  They need to find others who have either suffered or inflicted suffering -- the only ones who could be eye witnesses.

The film stays close to the book, but focusses on the relationships among friends and family before drawing the viewer into the action.  The book notes that a document in the US embassy intelligence files wrongly labelled Charles a subversive, perhaps sealing his fate.

Political Aftermath.

The Chilean economy was stabilized by Pinochet's government, and over twelve years the middle class flourished.  Hence there are widely divergent views of Pinochet's qualities as a national leader: economic savior or human rights violator?

In the mid 1990s, the aging former dictator flew to Europe for medical attention and was indicted in several European countries for allegedly murdering their citizens.  The British arrested him for extradition and the case was heard by the highest court: should he be extradicted to stand trial in Spain or France, or should he be released since the British had little case against him?  The court found against Pinochet -- but the case was reheard after one of the judges was found to have a wife active in Amnesty International.  Pinochet was released.

Author and Director.

The film is based on a recommended book by the family's lawyer, Thomas Hauser, The Execution of Charles Horman. 

The film is directed by Costa Gavras, born in Greece but educated in Paris.  His first film, "The Sleeping Car Murders" (1965) won awards; this third, "Z" won major awards in Cannes, New York and around the world.  "Z" was a thinly disguised outcry against the repressive Greek Colonels revolt against democracy in 1968.  His next (slower but harder-hitting) films made in France dealing with similar themes of repression are "Confession" and "State of Siege" (apparently about the Argentinian Tupamaro struggle). In the latter, a subtheme is US complicity in training Latin counterintelligence officers in torture.

Missing is a more commercial, briefer, more American film, more accessible to a mass audience.  It is focussed on the father, son and daughter in law rather than on the broader societal issues.  Already facing deterioration and distribution issues on celluloid, it has only been found lately on 16mm and in a magenta-toned print with poor sound quality.  It can however be found on videotape in reasonably good quality.

For a fine black & white documentary of smuggled television coverage of the coup -- including a scene in which the cameraman films his own death --  see the Battle of Chile.  In several parts, at some length, this documentary was a staple of college film nights in the 1970s.

Suggested Questions.

Some questions raised are the nature of human rights, reason of state, the rationale for coup d'etats against a democracy, patriotism to an unjust regime, civilian control of the military, martial law in a democracy, and the domestic role of a policeman versus that of a soldier.  

If a brutal dictator arranges an amnesty for his crimes in his own country, can he be tried in another? 

Should the US deal with brutal regimes in order to further its trade interests -- or should it attempt to improve their behavior on human rights at the expense of trade?

Increasingly, crimes against humanity are being tried under the UN convention against genocide in the Hague court; witness the trials of war criminals in Serbia.  But could this be used one day against American bomber pilots?

Epilogue.

Happily, in the 1990s virtually the whole of Latin America suddenly enjoyed democratic regimes -- one by one, military juntas and dictatorships collapsed.  By 2000, the North American Free Trade Agreement led to booming trade and a Free Trade of the Americas treaty was being developed -- to include the entire western hemisphere, now both democratic and market based.
 
Top Iconof page CorkPSC Home Page
CorkPSC Courses Index
CorkPSC Outlines Index
Mail IconComments

Building with Leaves Stripe