Huntingdon
College: Political Science Program | Courses
| Club News | What's
New?
PSC
311 and PSC 305 Outlines:
PBS video, Debating
Our Destiny:
40 years of Presidential
Debate
by Jeremy Lewis.
Jim Lehrer; Video, PBS, 2000; 1 (800) PlayPBS
[First 60 minutes – Stock Policy Speeches;
then 20 minutes – Gaffes and Flubs that tend to dominate media coverage.]
Possible Debate Effect -
-
Voting?
-
Civic Community?
-
Candidates?
The debates:
1960 JFK v RMN
– TV and radio; important visuals versus voice
1976 GRF v JEC
– gaffes: GRF East Europe; JEC Playboy interview
VP – Dole v Mondale – Dole gaffes:
Dem Wars, bunny vote, pardon
1980 (JEC) RWR v
Anderson – 2 way
1980 Carter v Reagan: ‘Asking
Amy’ about nuclear disarmament.
1984 Mondale v Reagan: Mondale
on deficit – First Debate
There you go again backfired;
Mondale had comeback.
RWR - Meandered – he claims he was over-trained.
Second Debate – RWR did better on foreign
policy and defense.
1984 Vice Presidential:
Bush – Did one (1) presidential
debate and five (5) vice-presidential debates.
Felt contrived and artificial. Worried
about his language.
Ferraro – Only three times in HR,
so political risk.
She felt she was standing in for American
women – major responsibility.
Tried to establish serious on foreign
policy. "Don’t patronize me".
1988 Bush v Dukakis
Dukakis – Felt did better on
first than second debate.
But gave short answer to Bernie Shaw's
death penalty/wife’s rapist question.
‘Passion-less’ question hurt Dukakis
Bush was more joking, relaxed.
1988 VP Quayle v Bentsen
Quayle – Prepared excessively,
wooden – but used liberal word.
Bentsen – Senator: You’re no Jack Kennedy.
1992 Bush v Clinton
Bush - Again reluctant, especially
with Perot.
Polls showed Perot will received.
Clinton - Surprised. Thought he had done
well.
Town Meeting – Bush looked at watch.
1992 VP Gore, Quayle and Stockdale
Gore – Praised Stockdale and put down
Quayle.
Stockdale – Unprepared – Only notified
days before. Perot forgot to tell him and they never conversed about politics.
1996 Dole v Clinton
Dole – Learned in ’76 to know
briefing material.
Clinton – Was ready for personal questions,
but Dole declined.
Clinton ran on strong record and was ahead
in the polls.
Dole at 73 worried about age question.
1996 VP - Kemp v Gore
Kemp – Missed chance to criticize
Gore/Clinton. Even missed a soft question on ethics.
Clinton – Debates may not change votes,
but force candidates to consider what they’ll defend.